Skip to main content

Water Pepper Rivaled a Chemical Spray on Rice Grasshoppers

Lemnsah Andrew Banboye, Konkuk University, Department of Bioresources and Food Science (MS student; supervisors Prof. Se Chul Chun and Prof. Doo Hwan Kim) · Cameroon

Two one-season rice trials tested boiled plant extracts as insect sprays. On Konkuk's natural farming paddy in Paju, water pepper, tobacco leaf and neem sprays cut pest counts to a fraction of the unsprayed plots while dragonflies stayed; in the lab, water pepper and tobacco killed every grasshopper within two days. On a conventional farm in Yeoju, water pepper extract held grasshoppers and stink bugs about as low as the chemical cypermethrin, but not stem borers.

What they found

The question

Can boiled plant extracts (chili pepper, lemon peel, water pepper, tobacco leaf, neem oil) control rice insect pests, and how do they compare with a chemical insecticide (cypermethrin)?

How they tested it

2016 season (dates not stated). Lab screen: 6 cages of 10 green grasshoppers; each extract sprayed onto one cage for 2 seconds, one untreated cage; survival read at 1 h, 2 h, 1 day and 2 days (one cage per treatment, no replication). Experiment I, Paju (Konkuk natural farming paddy, same field as the previous speaker's): 0.2 ha swamp rice plot, soil amended with 0.4 t IMO, Chucheong variety transplanted at 30 x 15 cm, 8-15 seedlings per hill; water control, hand weeding; nutrients from natural farming solutions (FAA, BRV, LAB, WSCP, seawater, WSC and minerals; one item hidden). 24 plots of 5 x 5 m in 2 blocks of 12; 6 treatments x 4 replicates, RCBD; sprays at 15, 30, 45, 60, 75 and 90 days after transplanting; 12 hills per plot measured. Experiment II, Yeoju (conventional farm): Hopum variety machine-transplanted at the same spacing; 4.5 kg NPK at 14 days and 4.5 kg N at 80 days (area not stated); herbicides for weeds; 5 treatments x 4 replicates, RCBD; sprays at 21, 42, 63 and 84 days. Statistical test not named; slides show significance letters. Grain yield not reported.

What was compared
  • Chili pepper extract (Capsicum annuum) — Plant material boiled 8 hours, diluted 1:15, foliar spray. Active molecule per slide: capsaicin. Both experiments.
  • Lemon peel extract (Citrus limon) — Boiled 8 hours, diluted 1:15, foliar spray. Limonene. Lab and Paju only.
  • Water pepper extract (Persicaria longiseta, Korean 'yeokkwi') — Boiled 8 hours, diluted 1:15, foliar spray. Both experiments.
  • Tobacco leaf extract (Nicotiana tabacum) — Boiled 8 hours, diluted 1:15, foliar spray. Nicotine. Lab and Paju only.
  • Neem oil (Azadirachta indica) — 1:5000 in Yeoju; Paju dilution not stated separately. Azadirachtin.
  • Pyretan (cypermethrin), chemical — 1:1000, Yeoju only.
  • Control — No insecticide; whether plots were sprayed with water is not stated.
Results
  1. Lab: water pepper and tobacco killed all grasshoppers within 2 days

    Table 1, % surviving after 1 h / 2 h / 1 day / 2 days: tobacco 60/20/10/0; water pepper 80/70/50/0; chili 80/80/60/20; neem 100/100/80/20; lemon peel 100/100/100/60; control 100/100/100 (2-day cell hidden; spoken: all alive).

    ▶ 6:04 Said and shown on the slides

  2. Paju: rice water weevils 1.7-12.5 per plot with extracts vs 17.0 untreated

    Table 2: neem 1.7 (e), tobacco 4.2 (d), water pepper 5.5 (d), chili 7.7 (c), lemon 12.5 (b), control 17.0 (a).

    ▶ 7:16 Said and shown on the slides

  3. Paju: green grasshoppers 2.2 per plot with water pepper vs 13.7 untreated

    Table 2: water pepper 2.2 (d), neem 3.5 (cd), tobacco 3.7 (cd), chili 5.5 (bc), lemon 7.5 (b), control 13.7 (a).

    ▶ 7:16 Said and shown on the slides

  4. Paju: stem borers and stink bugs also lower with every extract

    Table 2: stem borers 1.2-2.5 vs 3.5 control; rice stink bugs 0.7 (tobacco) to 2.2 vs 3.2 control. Water pepper's stink-bug cell reads 2.2 with letter b while lemon's 2.2 carries ab.

    ▶ 7:23 From the slides

  5. Dragonflies were not reduced

    Table 2: 1.0-2.2 per plot with extracts vs 2.7 control, all letter a. The speaker also saw many spiders; spiders were not counted on the slide.

    ▶ 7:46 Said and shown on the slides

  6. Water pepper gave shorter plants but the most panicles

    Table 3: height 83.5 cm (b) vs 89.7-93.0 (a) for all others; tillers 20.0 vs 15.0 control (all extracts 17.5-20.0 share letter a); fertile panicles 19.7 (a) vs 14.2 (c) control, 16.2-18.2 for other extracts. Every extract raised tillers and panicles over the control. Shorter plants lodge less, the speaker says.

    ▶ 8:13 Said and shown on the slides

  7. Yeoju: water pepper matched cypermethrin on grasshoppers and stink bugs

    Table 4, insects per plot: green grasshopper cypermethrin 2.2 (c), water pepper 2.7 (c), neem 3.5 (bc), chili 5.5 (b), control 8.0 (a); rice stink bug 2.2 (c), 2.5 (bc), 3.5 (bc), 4.2 (b), control 6.2 (a).

    ▶ 8:58 Said and shown on the slides

  8. Yeoju: water pepper did not control stem borer; cypermethrin did

    Table 4, stem borer: cypermethrin 0.7 (b), water pepper 2.2 (a), neem 2.0 (ab), chili 1.7 (ab), control 2.7 (a). Brown grasshopper: cypermethrin 0.5 (c), water pepper 1.2 (bc), control 2.7 (a). The talk's 'similar performance' holds for two of four pests.

    ▶ 9:07 From the slides

  9. No beneficial insects in the chemical (conventional) plots, per the speaker

    Slide footnote: cypermethrin is non-selective, 'no beneficial insects here as in natural farming plot Table 2'. Table 4 has no beneficial-insect column, so this was not counted.

    ▶ 9:15 Said and shown on the slides

Hold it loosely
  • One season; each experiment at one site.
  • Lab screen: one cage of 10 grasshoppers per treatment, no replication.
  • No grain yield was reported, though the conclusion says the extracts 'can improve rice productivity'.
  • Paju and Yeoju differ in farm system, variety, fertilizer and spray schedule, so the two experiments cannot be compared directly; lemon and tobacco were not tested in Yeoju.
  • The beneficial-insect claim for chemical plots is not backed by counts on the slides.
  • Statistical test not named; one Table 2 cell has inconsistent letters.
  • Spoken 'five times' for the Paju sprays; the slide lists six dates.
  • Tobacco extract is nicotine, itself a broad nerve poison (the slide notes it interrupts cholinesterase); safety and residues were not tested.
For your farm
  • Boiled water pepper, tobacco leaf and neem sprays helped keep rice pests far below unsprayed plots in this trial, while dragonflies stayed.
  • Water pepper extract at 1:15 held grasshoppers and stink bugs about as low as cypermethrin; for stem borer it did not.
  • Recipe used: boil the plant material 8 hours, dilute 1:15, spray leaves about every 15-21 days.
  • Water pepper-treated rice was shorter yet carried the most panicles; shorter rice lodges less.

Next to Master Cho's teaching

  • Agrees

    Boiled hot-pepper water as a spray Cho's hot-pepper water boils 10-12 peppers in 1 L down to half, then mixes it into 20 L of water, to repel aphids; the trial's boiled chili extract is the same idea at a different ratio (1:15) and against different pests.

    Soap-water-and-Hot-pepper-water, p. 2–7

  • Differs

    Kill pests vs grow plants they don't attack Cho says it matters more to grow plants that pests don't attack in the first place; pests follow excess nitrogen and nutrient imbalance. The talk tests sprays to kill insects and does not look at plant condition.

    Cho recipe book (scan), p. 30

  • Agrees

    Repel, don't spray indiscriminately, on rice Cho warns that harsh sprays harm soil life and, for rice leaf roller and stem borer, prefers repellents over blanket spraying; the trial's point that plant extracts left dragonflies, while the chemical left no beneficials, fits this.

    2017/Advanced Cho/advanced fruit/IMG_3201 @ 1:39:50 (translated)

  • Agrees

    Tobacco against insects Cho's book (read in Pure KNF Office Hours) lists tobacco as the usual material for the herbal smoker against greenhouse pests; the trial used it as a boiled leaf spray instead.

    Office Hours/Recordings - Video/oh116-240310 @ 0:55:29

“When the world will change and adopt natural farming, surely insects and other pests will also change the strategy to survive.”

▶ 1:34

“One thing to remark is that there was the presence of beneficial insects. We had a lot of dragonflies in the field, and spiders.”

▶ 7:46

“Water pepper in particular had a similar performance to cypermethrin, a chemical pesticide.”

▶ 8:58

In this talk

  1. 0:00Intro
  2. 0:45Rice insect pests
  3. 1:18Why natural pesticides
  4. 1:56Two experiments: Paju and Yeoju
  5. 2:23The five plant extracts
  6. 3:48Lab screen on grasshoppers
  7. 4:13Paju field trial design
  8. 4:54Yeoju conventional trial
  9. 6:04Lab results
  10. 7:08Field pest counts
  11. 8:04Plant height, tillers, panicles
  12. 8:45Water pepper vs cypermethrin
  13. 9:31Conclusion

Transcript

Transcribed and checked by hand against the recording. Click any time to play from there.