Skip to main content

No Antibiotics, No Vaccines: A Pig Farmer on Food and Health

David Wong, Natural farming pig farmer, Oʻahu, Hawaiʻi (formerly in cattle, about 2,500 head) · United States (Hawaiʻi)

A Hawaiʻi pig farmer who started with nine piglets in 2012 says his farm uses no antibiotics, vaccines, hormones or steroids and came through two local disease outbreaks without trouble. He then argues, with news clippings and US disease graphs, that drugs in livestock and chemicals in food harm human health, and closes by telling the room he has cancer and is treating it with food alone.

What they found

The question

Main claim: natural farming, which raises animals without antibiotics, vaccines, hormones or steroids, gives healthier food, and food has a direct effect on human health.

How they tested it

Personal farm experience and a review of news items and published graphs, not a study. The farm (in Hawaiʻi; name not caught) started with nine piglets in 2012. Herd size today, feed, housing, natural farming solutions used, growth rates and disease records are not stated. Slides: World Health Organization 'causes of antibiotic resistance', NPR (11/4/2013 and 3/20/2015), Reuters (4/8/2016), CIA World Factbook life expectancy 2015, CDC diabetes 1958–2014, autism and Parkinson's graphs plotted against glyphosate use, Alzheimer's cost projections, and David B. Agus's book The End of Illness.

What was compared
  • The speaker's natural farming pig farm — No antibiotics, no vaccines, no hormones, no steroids (slide and speech). No other details of feed or solutions given.
Results
  1. Pigs raised since 2012 with no antibiotics, vaccines, hormones or steroids, 'doing quite well'

    Started with nine baby pigs in 2012. People told him it could not succeed. No herd numbers, weights or mortality given.

    ▶ 1:09 Said and shown on the slides

  2. Two disease outbreaks nearby; farm quarantined twice, no problems

    The state veterinarian saw the farm as highly susceptible because it does not vaccinate. The disease is not named.

    ▶ 3:40 As spoken

  3. FDA moved to revoke a pig drug approved in 1972 over cancer risk

    Slide (Reuters, 4/8/2016): could leave a cancerous residue; used against swine dysentery and bacterial enteritis but also to promote weight gain; approved 44 years ago. The speaker says 'banned'; the slide says 'to revoke'. The drug is not named.

    ▶ 4:37 Said and shown on the slides

  4. Antibiotics are fed to livestock partly because animals gain weight faster

    Slide (NPR, 11/4/2013): 'feeding small amounts of antibiotics to animals in order to make them grow faster.' World map (NPR, 3/20/2015): regions producing the most pork and chicken use the most antibiotics.

    ▶ 5:35 Said and shown on the slides

  5. The US ranks 43rd in life expectancy, at 79.7 years

    Slide: CIA World Factbook 2015; Monaco first at 89.5, Japan 84.7, Taiwan 40th at 80.0. He contrasts this with US spending on health insurance.

    ▶ 12:10 Said and shown on the slides

  6. Autism and Parkinson's rates rise in step with glyphosate (Roundup) use

    Slide graphs: autism R = 0.9886; Parkinson's deaths R = 0.860 against glyphosate, R = 0.937 against % GE corn and soy. Correlations only. He says: 'I'm not necessarily telling you that's bad or good.'

    ▶ 14:30 Said and shown on the slides

  7. The speaker has cancer and is treating it with food alone; his cancer counts are falling

    No surgery, radiation or chemo. His doctors advised against it. Cancer type, the 'counts' and the time frame are not given.

    ▶ 18:51 As spoken

Hold it loosely
  • An opinion talk, not a study: no farm data (herd size, growth, mortality, disease tests) are shown.
  • The disease graphs show correlations over time; correlation does not show cause, and many things changed over the same years.
  • The cancer account is one person, with no diagnosis, stage or measurements given.
  • The life-expectancy ranking is not tied to farming practice by any data in the talk.
  • No natural farming methods or solutions are described.
  • The FDA item was a move to revoke approval (per the slide), not a completed ban.
For your farm
  • One Hawaiʻi farm reports raising pigs since 2012 with no antibiotics, vaccines, hormones or steroids, and coming through two local outbreaks without disease.
  • Growth-promoting antibiotics in feed are an economic choice; a natural farming herd can be raised without them.
  • Know your food source: we are what we eat, and what it eats.

Next to Master Cho's teaching

  • Agrees

    Pigs raised without antibiotics or medicine Cho describes natural farming pig houses as 'no odor, no medicine, no noise' and says pork soaked with antibiotics and growth hormones can never reach natural farming quality.

    Cho, Janong Natural Farming (2003), p. 189

  • Agrees

    Antibiotic overuse in conventional livestock Cho's pig presentation lists saving antibiotic and medical costs as a feature of natural farming livestock and cites KBS data on antibiotic use per 10,000 t of livestock.

    Natural-Farming-Pig, p. 8–32

  • Goes further

    Healthy animals come through outbreaks without vaccines Cho cites stress hormones about 10 times lower in natural farming pigs and says they get little or no disease; he does not address vaccination directly.

    2017/Advanced Cho/swine/IMG_1464 @ 0:02:35 (translated)

  • Agrees

    Food quality and human health Cho separates 'safe food' (free of pathogens) from 'healthy food', and says natural farming aims at the second.

    2017/Advanced Cho/advanced fruit/IMG_3462 @ 0:00:00 (translated)

“One of the interesting things that has happened on our farm is we do not use antibiotics. We don't use any vaccines.”

▶ 1:09

“We are what we eat, and importantly, what it eats.”

▶ 18:05

“I am your test case. I have cancer. I am being treated solely with nutritious food.”

▶ 18:51

In this talk

  1. 0:00Nine piglets in 2012
  2. 1:09No antibiotics, vaccines, hormones, steroids
  3. 2:10Hormones in cattle
  4. 3:21Vaccines and two quarantines
  5. 4:08Antibiotic resistance
  6. 4:37FDA moves against a pig drug
  7. 5:35Antibiotics for growth
  8. 6:13World antibiotic use map
  9. 6:29Natural farming and human health
  10. 8:19Lessons from smoking
  11. 11:02US life expectancy: 43rd
  12. 12:42Dr. David Agus
  13. 13:37Diabetes, autism, Parkinson's, Alzheimer's
  14. 17:25Know your food source
  15. 18:51"I am your test case"
  16. 19:48Closing charge

Transcript

Transcribed and checked by hand against the recording. Click any time to play from there.