Skip to main content

From a 6×6 Bed to 8 Acres: Natural Farming in School Gardens

Donna Mitts, Drake Weinert, Robert Kobayashi, ʻIwalani Haia, Keliʻi Akina, Jenny, Mark Fontaine, Lou, Hawaiʻi Island school garden teachers and staff; Kohala Center School Garden Network · USA (Hawaiʻi)

Donna Mitts of the Kohala Center's Hawaiʻi Island School Garden Network introduces staff from four schools: Kalanianaʻole (Drake Weinert), Waiākea High (Robert Kobayashi), Kamehameha Schools (ʻIwalani Haia, Keliʻi Akina) and Laupāhoehoe Community Public Charter School (Jenny, Mark Fontaine, Lou). They show their gardens, pig pens and animals, and talk about money, administrators and cafeteria rules. Natural farming comes up as Microbes (IMO), Protectors (LAB), bone-based calcium and natural-farming pig pens. Nobody gives a rate or a measured result.

What they found

The question

How are Hawaiʻi Island schools running gardens and animal projects with natural farming, and what gets in the way?

How they tested it

A panel of programs, not a trial. Kalanianaʻole: Drake Weinert started as an after-school K–8 program, then was hired as the intermediate agriculture instructor; in-school two years, now with an assistant. Garden on former lawn with metal beds, a greenhouse, taro, cassava, bananas, sweet potatoes, basil; paper-waste compost, weed mat, logs and wood chips; no poisons. Waiākea High: an elective natural resources program in the career and technical education department, with a shade house, hydroponics, aquaculture tanks, a 1980s tractor, cattle from the teacher's ranch, goats, sheep, chickens and ducks, and a Korean natural farming pig pen about three to four years old. Kamehameha Schools: a mainstream (not elective) Hawaiian culture class that every high school student takes; the mala began on a compacted road area about 10 years ago and is now said to be 8 acres; chickens, goats in paddocks, aquaponics, a natural farming piggery being built by students; solutions made in 5-gallon buckets. Laupāhoehoe charter (K–12, 34–36 acre campus): a fenced garden ("I don't know if it's a 160-foot" area), greenhouse, orchard, a piggery finished but with no pig yet, a 4-day-a-week all-local snack program. Not stated: student numbers per program (except Laupāhoehoe's 150 fed), garden budgets, harvest weights, any recipe amounts or dilution rates.

What was compared
  • Microbes (IMO) made by students — Kalanianaʻole kids make IMO (photo, t≈2691); Kamehameha makes its solutions in 5-gallon buckets because of how much it sprays. No amounts or rates given.
  • Protectors (LAB) from chocolate milk — Kalanianaʻole: 'We made it from chocolate milk.' No other steps given.
  • Microbes back in after weed mat and tilling — Laupāhoehoe: weed-mat one half of the garden for a year, then flip; reintroduce IMO after pulling the mat and tilling, because they were told tilling kills the beneficial bacteria. No rate given.
  • Bone calcium at home — Kamehameha teaches students they can make 'water-soluble calcium' and 'burn their chicken bones' at home without money. No recipe given.
  • Natural farming pig pens — Waiākea has one about three to four years old; Kamehameha students are building one on a hill over a dug pit with biochar; Laupāhoehoe built one in its first year. Waiākea plans to spread the built-up bedding on the garden as it is.
Results
  1. More than 60 school garden programs on Hawaiʻi Island

    Network started around 2003 after a Rocky Mountain Institute report commissioned by the Kohala Center; free teacher workshops; curriculum by grade on its website.

    ▶ 2:05 Said and shown on the slides

  2. FoodCorps: about 13 service members statewide this year

    Hosted in Hawaiʻi by the Kohala Center; on Oʻahu, Molokaʻi, Maui and Hawaiʻi Island. Three cohorts of Kū ʻĀina Pā, a year-long garden teacher training.

    ▶ 4:57 Said and shown on the slides

  3. Garden grew from a 6×6 bed to 8 acres over 10 years

    Started on a compacted, rock-filled area the school called 'your mala'; each student brought one stone ('600 pounds of stones later'); no money and no soil, so they composted shredded paper and scraps. The school now invests in it.

    ▶ 20:16 As spoken

  4. 100% of Kamehameha's high school students go through the mala

    It is a mainstream class, not an elective.

    ▶ 21:08 As spoken

  5. No outside fertilizer, no bought chicken manure

    Goats in paddocks and their own chickens supply manure.

    ▶ 22:17 As spoken

  6. Solutions made in 5-gallon buckets, not glass jars

    Because of the amount they spray; 20–30 senior projects a year.

    ▶ 1:19:25 As spoken

  7. One cassava plant: 60 to 80 pounds

    His estimate, shown with a harvest photo; no weighing described.

    ▶ 47:23 As spoken

  8. Grass 'just pulls out of the ground so easy'

    He credits microbes aerating the soil. Observation only.

    ▶ 47:52 As spoken

  9. Garden food eaten in the garden, not the cafeteria

    Smoothies from bananas and sugar cane, with basil to get kids to try new tastes; a solar oven and a propane burner for sweet potatoes. Easier than cafeteria rules.

    ▶ 43:03 As spoken

  10. A cafeteria uses about 70 pounds of lettuce per meal, per day

    Why the school garden can't replace a supply line yet. Poi or kalo on the line would cost the school 'about $800 per meal'.

    ▶ 32:08 As spoken

  11. Public schools must be able to supply every school; charter schools don't

    Each charter school is its own school food authority; the public-school rule means supplying about 100,000 meals a day. A Charter School Food Working Group aims to form buying groups.

    ▶ 36:26 As spoken

  12. Snack program: 100% local, 4 days a week, 150 kids, for 3 years

    Ordered from farmers and distributors such as Adaptations. A monthly Farm to School lunch ran two years and is 'dying out'. Started with a 2012 USDA Farm to School planning grant.

    ▶ 1:25:31 As spoken

  13. Weed mat half the garden for a year, then put microbes back

    They till regularly because the soil compacts; IMO is reintroduced after the mat comes off and the soil is tilled.

    ▶ 1:26:24 As spoken

  14. Piggery finished after year one, then stalled

    Rebuilt the chicken coop with four laying hens, then built the piggery with a grant; ran out of administrator support and money. Mark Fontaine hopes to get a pig in this year.

    ▶ 29:34 As spoken

  15. FFA chapter grew from 5 to 16 students

    Natural resources is the only growing program in Waiākea's career and technical education department.

    ▶ 55:49 As spoken

  16. Three-to-four-year KNF pig pen bedding to go straight on the garden

    Following Mike DuPonte's advice to 'throw it right in', though someone told him to heat it first to kill pathogens.

    ▶ 1:09:36 As spoken

  17. Open aquaponics: fresh water to the fish, fish water to the plants

    Also converted a fish tank to a filterless system with only air. Some younger-student field trips were cancelled last year for lack of time.

    ▶ 1:15:01 As spoken

Hold it loosely
  • Program descriptions and stories, not trials: no controls, no measured yields, no soil tests.
  • No recipe amounts, dilution rates or schedules are given for any solution.
  • Numbers are from memory (8 acres, 600 pounds of stones, 60–80 lb of cassava, $800 per meal, 70 lb of lettuce); the Laupāhoehoe garden size was given with 'I don't know if it's'.
  • Drake Weinert, a panelist, founded the Pure KNF Foundation, which publishes this site.
  • Several stretches are garbled in both transcripts and are marked [unclear]; one panelist's surname (Lou) and Jenny's surname were not stated or not audible.
For your farm
  • Start with what's free: shredded paper and food scraps for compost, stones from home, wood chips, logs, weed mat over grass.
  • Plant crops that survive school breaks: taro, cassava, bananas, sweet potatoes.
  • If cafeteria rules block garden food, serve it in the garden or class: smoothies, a solar oven, culinary class.
  • Make solutions in 5-gallon buckets if you spray a large area.
  • Get administrators on side early, or build a Farm to School committee of staff, parents, cafeteria managers and nonprofits so it isn't one person.
  • Use a permission form for tools like weed whackers and mowers; the Kohala Center school garden site has a sample.
  • Watch food safety when kids eat from the garden; panelists named rat lungworm.

Next to Master Cho's teaching

  • Differs

    Protectors (LAB) made from chocolate milk Cho cultures rice-wash water first, then adds it to plain milk at 10 parts milk to 1. Chocolate milk is not in his recipe; the panel gives no steps or result, so the added sugar and cocoa are untested here.

    Cho, Natural Farming Agricultural Materials (Recipe), p. 55

  • Differs

    Students burn chicken bones for calcium Cho makes bone calcium (Structure, WCP) from charred bones in brown rice vinegar and says chicken bone isn't as good as cow, pig or fish bone. In his system 'water-soluble calcium' (Reproduction, WCA) comes from eggshells, not bones.

    Cho - DVD rips/UNTITLED_DISC @ 0:50:03 (translated)

  • Differs

    Tilling regularly, then adding microbes back Cho says there is no tilling in natural farming; covered soil lets microbes and earthworms do the work. Laupāhoehoe's weed mat is close to his covering idea; the regular tilling is not.

    Cho, Janong Natural Farming (2010 draft), p. 21

  • Agrees

    Bringing students into natural farming Cho later (2017) said he needed a way for students and young farmers to enter natural farming and tried to set up a university program. He did not speak about school gardens at this event; he was not there.

    2017/Advanced Cho/advanced fruit/IMG_3219 @ 0:04:25 (translated)

“600 pounds of stones later, we have a mala.”

▶ 19:20

“When students grow the food and have their hands in the dirt, they're more likely to eat it.”

▶ 25:08

“You've gotta have this support from the top.”

▶ 28:43

“Natural resources is glamorous, but agriculture is sweaty.”

▶ 1:01:15

“My policy is we go forward and we apologize after.”

▶ 1:23:03

“There's something for you in our garden.”

▶ 12:26

In this talk

  1. 0:00Donna Mitts: the School Garden Network and its curriculum
  2. 7:05Drake Weinert, Kalanianaʻole: why teach keiki in a garden
  3. 13:46Robert Kobayashi, Waiākea High: from auto shop to ag
  4. 17:59ʻIwalani Haia, Kamehameha Schools: the mala as classroom
  5. 18:50Keliʻi Akina: no money, no dirt, now 8 acres
  6. 23:42Jenny, Laupāhoehoe charter: Farm to School
  7. 25:37Mark Fontaine: keeping the piggery going
  8. 27:31Lou: building an ag school as head custodian
  9. 31:10Q&A: can garden food reach the cafeteria?
  10. 35:29Donna Mitts: school food authorities and buying groups
  11. 39:41Q&A: free meals, food safety, rat lungworm
  12. 42:36Drake: smoothies and cooking in the garden
  13. 44:12Drake: photo tour of the Kalanianaʻole garden
  14. 50:46Robert Kobayashi: the Waiākea natural resources program
  15. 57:16Robert: challenges, enrollment and soft skills
  16. 1:06:53Robert: cattle, goats and the KNF pig pen
  17. 1:12:30Robert: hydroponics, aquaponics, repairs
  18. 1:17:49Q&A: liability and permission forms
  19. 1:19:09Keliʻi Akina: Kamehameha projects and the moon calendar
  20. 1:22:56Keliʻi: going ahead without admin support
  21. 1:23:23Jenny: how to start Farm to School
  22. 1:28:38Close

Transcript

Transcribed and checked by hand against the recording. Click any time to play from there.