Skip to main content

← All questions

Asked by wegrzyn.andy ·June 25, 2024 ·13.9k readers

Original Maintenace Solution

In KNF Recipe Book there is WCaP added in Maintenance Solution (MS) while there is none in nutritive-cycle.pdf. Also other KNF leaders (eg. Chris Trump) don't include WCaP in MS. Some say that for vegetative growth WCaP shouldn't be used. Drake told me why WCaP is important in all stages and I totally agree. But somehow it still bothers me... I assume both these recipes come from Master Cho. When the shift was made?

Top answer

From the KNF library

From the KNF library Drafted by Claude from Office Hours and the books · Sep 2026 · 4 sources

The Student's Manual makes Maintenance Solution from FPJ, OHN and vinegar. It has no structure solution in it. (Student's Manual, Basic Course, p. 46)

KNF Demystified also lists the basic maintenance spray as OHN, FPJ and BRV. (KNF Demystified, p. 5) An Office Hours answer says calcium phosphate is KNF Structure (WCP), used in the maintenance solution. (Office Hours Ep. 54, 6:56) So the library holds one mix without WCP and one with it. (Student's Manual, Basic Course, p. 46) (Office Hours Ep. 54, 6:56)

Drake's reason for WCP: structure is a basic need, like food, cleanser and medicine, in Master Cho's method. It is needed at all times except right before harvest. (Office Hours Ep. 130, 31:53) That speaks to the worry about vegetative growth. The library names one time to skip structure, and it is not the vegetative stage. (Office Hours Ep. 130, 31:53)

The library does not say when the shift happened or who first added WCP to the mix.

1 more answer
suze · Feb 8, 2025
I'll just add, Master Cho did not come up with "Maintenance Solution" or ever spoke of it. Drake came up with MS by looking at the common denominators of each of Cho's formulations. At first we combined food, cleanser and medicine and ran with that for several years. Later Drake noticed knfStructure (WCAP) was also a common denominator in almost all the Cho's formations, so that was added into MS. In practice I can tell you the knfStructure is vital.

Also discussed on Office Hours

Know the answer? Members answer and ask questions here.

Sign in Become a member