Skip to main content

← All questions

Asked by zacharypinegar ·September 6, 2020 ·17.9k readers

Making vinegar

Is there a reason I can't make vinegar out of my FFJ residue? I know that it is done with FPJ typically but I can't reason out why I shouldn't? Any thoughts?

Top answer

From the KNF library

From the KNF library Drafted by Claude from Office Hours and the books · Sep 2026 · 5 sources

Drake sees no reason to hold back. He says the difference between FFJ and FPJ is "none that matters" because it is all plant food. (Office Hours Aug 2025, 50:58)

He also prefers vinegar to rewashing. After draining the juice, he says it is better to turn the leftovers into vinegar than to rewash the mash for more juice. (Office Hours Oct 2025, 32:39)

On the why, Drake says a fermented liquid left open to air turns to vinegar. Alcohol only stays alcohol if sealed airtight. (Office Hours Ep. 17, 30:20) He also says adding water to FPJ turns it into vinegar. (Office Hours Ep. 28, 54:50)

When the vinegar is done, strain off the solids. Then lightly raise the temperature so scobies stop growing back. (Office Hours Ep. 53, 7:33)

The library gives no ratio for residue itself. It says nothing about low sugar in the leftover material.

2 more answers
hugoflmatos · Oct 3, 2020
It doesn't matter if you're using FPJ or FFJ leftover, both work just fine. But it does take some time, guive it a couple months, or add to it a little bit of some vinegar wich is alive to jump start it.
suze · Jan 6, 2021
sometimes if there isn't enough sugar present in the fpj plant material it wont make a food vinegar. I find making it from the juice itself gives more consistent results. 1/3 plant juice 2/3 water, a splash of raw vinegar or a vinegar scoby. cover with breathable lid. if you have a well developed scoby it will speed up the process significantly. without adding any vinegar or scoby to inoculate the brew it can take up to 5 months to make vinegar. but you'll grow your own scoby in the process.

Also discussed on Office Hours

Know the answer? Members answer and ask questions here.

Sign in Become a member